SPAIN: Goodwill Compensation in hospitality leases. Confirmation by the Spanish Supreme Court.

Mercedes CLAVELL | SPAIN | 17 July 2026

Mercedes CLAVELL

View CV

It is well known that offline retail trade usually takes place in leased premises: the retailer—whether a distributor, franchisee or independent trader—operates a business in a property owned by a third party. This separation between ownership of the premises and management of the business through a lease agreement is also common in the hospitality sector.

In this article, we analyse a recent ruling by the Spanish Supreme Court which confirms a point of particular practical interest: compensation for goodwill or clientele payable by the landlord, as provided for in certain cases of termination of the lease agreement, may also apply to premises used for hospitality purposes, such as hotels, bars and restaurants. The ruling specifically concerns a bar with a terrace, although the criteria it sets out are applicable to other hospitality businesses.

1. Goodwill Compensation: from agency to other legal concepts

Goodwill compensation as provided for in Directive 86/653/EEC on Self Employed Commercial Agents — transposed into the national legal systems of the 27 EU Member States and with similar rules in other countries — is a mechanism widely known to regular operators and has given rise to significant case law.

Its principles, with certain nuances, have also been applied to distribution contracts. However, in Spain, unlike the agency regime described in the Directive, the parties may agree to waive compensation in the distribution contract, and indeed it is common to find such a waiver in written distribution contracts, though not in tacit or informal agreements (such as agreements by email, for example).

2. Goodwill Compensation for clientele under Article 34 of the LAU: a lesser-known provision

Less well known, however, is the goodwill compensation (or compensation for clientele) regulated in article 34 of the Spanish Urban Leases Act (LAU). The LAU applies generally—to most property leases in Spain: residential properties (where a lot of provisions are mandatory), offices, retail premises, warehouses, industrial buildings and hotels, in respect of which there is greater freedom of contract. Although some of this type of leases could also be governed by the Civil Code, in practice many landlords prefer to bring them under the LAU as it provides a clear framework of rights and obligations and is backed by a substantial body of case law.

Excluded from the LAU are leases of parking spaces, operating industries and rural properties.

In the context of this discussion, the Supreme Court has recently confirmed the applicability of compensation for loss of clientele under Article 34 of the LAU—provided its requirements are met—in leases of premises intended for the hospitality industry.

3. Requirements for compensation under Article 34 of the LAU to apply:

For the right to compensation for clientele under Article 34 of the LAU to arise, the following requirements must be met:

  1. The lease must be for business premises, not residential property, and subject to the LAU.
  2. The tenant must have carried out a retail activity, including hospitality services, for the last 5 years.
  3. The contract must terminate due to the expiry of the term, not for any other reason.
  4. That, four months prior to the end of the contract, the tenant notifies the landlord in writing of their intention to extend the lease for a further five years, paying market rent, and that the landlord refuses.
  5. And, crucially, that the tenant has not waived this compensation in the lease agreement.

4. Calculation of compensation: two scenarios

For the purposes of quantification, the article distinguishes between two main situations:

A) The tenant continues the same business in the same municipality within the following six months.

If the tenant continues the same business in the same locality or municipality within the following six months, the compensation would include:

  • Relocation costs.
  • Loss of business due to loss of clientele, calculated as the difference in income during the first six months of operating the new premises.

B) The tenant does not continue the same business

If the tenant does not continue the same business activity, the compensation would be:

  • One month’s rent for each year of the terminated lease, up to a maximum of 20 monthly payments.

5. Waiver of compensation: importance of the contractual clause

For the waiver of compensation under Article 34 of the LAU to take effect, it is sufficient for it to be clear and in writing. In practice, a clause in the contract expressly stating that the tenant waives such compensation would suffice.

Furthermore, it is common for lease agreements subject to the LAU to include a waiver of other rights which the law, in principle, recognises for the tenant, such as:

  • Right of assignment.
  • Right to sublet.
  • Right of pre-emption in the event of the sale of the property.

Conclusion

The confirmation in case law of the applicability of Article 34 of the LAU to hospitality premises reinforces the need to review in detail lease agreements for this type of business premises . In particular, it is crucial to verify whether the legal requirements are met and, above all, whether the contract contains (or does not contain) an express waiver of compensation for loss of clientele, an aspect that can substantially alter the distribution of financial risks at the end of the lease.

Link to the ruling of the Spanish Supreme Court: Sentencia Tribunal Supremo Civil, sec. 1a, S 20 -02-2026, nº 2742026, rec. 18312021 .

Mercedes Clavell, IDI Country Expert for franchising in Spain.

Print this article