AUSTRALIA: Seminal cases in Australian franchising regulation for 2025

Anthony CONAGHAN | AUSTRALIA | 15 January 2026

Anthony CONAGHAN

View CV

Two recent cases in Australia have become seminal for the franchising industry in Australia. In July 2025, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia dismissed an appeal made by the applicants  in AHG WA (2015) Pty Ltd v Mercedes-Benz Australia/Pacific Pty Ltd [2025] FCAFC 86. Soon afterwards in August, the New South Wales Court of Appeal overturned a judgment against a franchisor in Netdeen Pty Ltd (t/as GJ Gardner Homes) v Lindfield NSW Pty Ltd [2025] NSWCA 196.

Both of these cases, while not at this stage final, provide guidance on several important legal risks for franchising in Australia. These include the relevance of goodwill in franchise relationships and liability for ‘unconscionable conduct’ under the Australian Consumer Law. 

MERCEDES-BENZ V AHG

This case is the outcome of a protracted dispute between Mercedez-Benz and 38 of its 49 car dealers in Australia. In summary, Merdeces-Benz ended several dealer agreements with its dealerships by issuing notices of non-renewal of those agreements. It had done so because it was now offering a new ‘agency’ model, whereby dealers would receive cars from Mercedes-Benz as agents and would sell them at prices and on the terms set by Mercedes-Benz directly. The dealers, in response, took action in the Federal Court in Melbourne alleging that this shift in the business model made by Mercedes-Benz amounted to unconscionable conduct.

The first instance Judgment was delivered by Beach J, and is extensive, numbering some 3752 paragraphs over 679 pages. An analysis of the underlying facts can be found at paragraph [971] to [2207] of Beach J’s judgment.

A particularly important aspect of this judgment is the discussion Beach J sets out regarding ‘goodwill’ in the context of franchising as opposed to a mere ‘accounting’ concept. Beach J adopted the interpretation advocated by Mercedes-Benz that goodwill is ‘tethered’ to the franchise agreements proposed and was subsequently lost when those agreements were ended. The implication from this is that goodwill is not subjective assessment of any business’s value but is to be objectively assessed according to the bargain made between two parties – particularly so between a franchisor and franchisee, where the ‘goodwill’ of the franchisor’s brand is integral to the franchise relationship.

This has particularly important implications for the Australian Franchising Code of Conduct, under section 42. This section provides that:

A franchisor must not enter into a franchise agreement that includes (in the agreement, or in another document physically attached to the agreement, or in another document incorporated into the agreement by reference) a restraint of trade clause that would apply if:

(a)            the franchise agreement expires; and

(b)            the franchise agreement contained an option for the franchisee to renew or extend the agreement; and

(c)            before the expiry, the franchisee had given written notice to the franchisor seeking to renew or extend the agreement on substantially the same terms as those:

(i)              contained in the franchisor’s current franchise agreement; and

(ii)             that apply to other franchisees or would apply to a prospective franchisee; and

(d)            before the expiry, the franchisee met any conditions contained in the franchise agreement that were required to be met by the franchisee to renew or extend the agreement; and

(e)            immediately before the expiry, the franchisee was not in serious breach of the agreement or any related agreement; and

(f)             the franchisee had not infringed the intellectual property of, or a confidentiality agreement with, the franchisor during the term of the agreement; and

(g)            the franchisor did not renew or extend the agreement; and

(h)            either:

(i)              the franchisee claimed compensation for goodwill because the agreement was not renewed or extended, but the compensation given was merely a nominal amount and did not provide genuine compensation for goodwill; or

(ii)             the agreement did not allow the franchisee to claim compensation for goodwill in the event that it was not renewed or extended.

Also see section 43 of the Code, which states that in calculating compensation to be given to franchisees for early termination of a franchise agreement on particular grounds, compensation is to be calculated with reference to, among other factors, ‘loss of opportunity in selling established goodwill’.

A common thread throughout these provisions of the Franchising Code is the implication that goodwill can be an important and valuable asset of a franchisee. However, as Beach J stated, goodwill cannot be separated from the commercial bargain that gave rise to it. It would be inappropriate for a franchisee to claim compensation for goodwill it developed solely through the resources and assistance provided by the franchisor – the Federal Court has recognised this, and has determined that goodwill must be ascertained contextually and based on this commercial bargain.

Equally important in the decision of Beach J is his discussion of unconscionable conduct. He found that, in effect, if a party is acting in accordance with the terms of an agreement between commercial parties that those parties agreed to be bound by, such actions cannot amount to ‘unconscionable conduct’. Accordingly, a franchisor is entitled to protect its legitimate commercial interests under an agreement, and cannot be deemed ‘unconscionable’ for doing so in accordance with that agreement.

The Federal Court was careful to specify that unconscionability is assessed with specific reference to a party’s rights under their agreement, and is not to be ascertained based on prevailing community sentiment. A franchise agreement would become ineffective if a party’s rights could be simply displaced by standards such as ‘community norms’.

LINDFIELD NSW V NETDEEN

This is a dispute between Netdeen Pty Ltd (the franchisor of the G.J. Gardner Homes franchise) and its former master franchisee for New South Wales, Lindfield NSW Pty Ltd. I am acting for Netdeen.

In summary, Lindfield was a Master Franchisee of G.J. Gardner Homes pursuant to a Master Franchise Agreement for a term of 10 years. In July of 2023, Lindfield gave notice to the franchisor that it sought to renew this agreement for another 10-year term. In response, the franchisor informed Lindfield that it has decided not to renew pursuant to its rights to refuse renewal under the Master Franchise Agreement. Lindfield proceeded to initiate proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, alleging that the franchisor had breached the Master Franchise Agreement by refusing to renew and had otherwise engaged in unconscionable conduct.

At the first instance, the Supreme Court of New South Wales found in favour of Lindfield. This decision was subsequently appealed – this appeal was allowed in part by the New South Wales Court of Appeal. It was found that Lindfield’s allegation that Netdeen had breached the Master Franchise Agreement was an issue to be remitted to a retrial. This retrial remains on foot and is expected to be heard in early 2026.

Not all of the issues in this proceeding were remitted for retrial, however. The Court of Appeal discussed at length the allegations of unconscionable conduct raised by Lindfield, dismissing this claim decisively. At paragraph [127], the NSW Court of Appeal stated that:

If Netdeen honestly believed on reasonable grounds that renewal was not in the best interests of the relevant parties specified in cl 4.7, as is assumed for the purpose of the ACL unconscionability claim, then it is not clear how exercising its rights under cl 4.7 could be regarded as contravening honest and reasonable standards of conduct, or as otherwise being in bad faith. This is particularly so in the light of the principles noted above, namely that good faith does not restrict a party from promoting its own legitimate interests or impose obligations inconsistent with the terms of the relevant agreement. Having regard to these principles, there is considerable force in Netdeen’s submission that compliance with the terms of cl 4.7 is dispositive of the issue of ACL unconscionable conduct given that the conduct that was said by Lindfield to be unconscionable was the non-renewal itself.

See also the Court of Appeal’s discussion regarding goodwill at [145]:

The fact that exercise of the non-renewal power deprived Lindfield of an asset which had grown in value (PJ3[47]) has little relevance in circumstances where the MFA contained not only cl 4.7, but also cl 14.6. The latter clause made clear that, upon termination or expiry of the MFA, Lindfield was not entitled to any payment, repayment or compensation for any goodwill attaching to the business.

There are some noticeable similarities in the decision of the Court of Appeal, and that of Beach J’s judgment in AHG v Mercedes-Benz. Firstly, is the strong position taken by the Court of Appeal that a party acting in accordance with a right it holds under a contract cannot be held to have acted unconscionably. ‘Honest and reasonable standards of conduct’ in a commercial context must be assessed by reference to the bargain made between two contracting parties.

Similarly, the Court of Appeal’s discussion of goodwill echoes the position taken by Beach J. A party’s entitlement to ‘goodwill’ is inevitably tethered to their commercial bargain, and where that bargain between the parties contemplates the exclusion of any entitlement to goodwill, that must be taken into account by the courts.

The abovementioned cases are valuable guidance for franchisors in entering into franchise agreements and managing their relationships with their franchisees. They provide welcome clarity that a franchisor that acts in accordance with their own agreement will not be liable for ‘unconscionable conduct’. Beyond this, however, they emphasise how important it is for franchisors in Australia to ensure their contracts and legal relationships are compliant with the Franchising Code of Conduct.

Anthony Conaghan, IDI Country Expert for franchising in Australia

Print this article